From “Rattling” to “Rusting”: A Forensic Engineering Report on AC Sheet Metal Field Failures

Why This Report Matters to HVAC Procurement Professionals

In today’s globalized and cost-sensitive HVAC supply chain, purchasing teams face mounting pressure to reduce failure risks while maintaining tight lead times and competitive pricing. Whether you’re sourcing custom HVAC sheet metal enclosures, waterproof outdoor cabinets, or high-volume electrical housings, understanding why fabricated AC sheet metal parts fail in the field is essential for making informed procurement decisions.

This report breaks down the four most common failure types that affect long-term reliability in AC sheet metal fabrication. You’ll learn:

  • What causes seemingly “perfect” parts to fail
  • How design flaws or missed QA steps lead to field issues
  • Why conventional vendors often fall short
  • How YISHANG’s engineering-first approach helps reduce risk and increase lifetime value

Let’s walk through each failure category with practical insight drawn from 26+ years of sheet metal engineering and global OEM supply partnerships.

Failure One: Oil-Canning, Vibration & Fastener Loosening

🔍 Common Symptoms

  • Loud “popping” or vibration sounds from HVAC panels
  • Visible flexing of sheet metal surfaces
  • Progressive loosening of fasteners or mounting points

These symptoms aren’t just cosmetic—they erode end-user trust and signal potential for system failure. In precision HVAC builds, a minor deformation in panel geometry can undermine overall equipment quality.

❌ What Causes It

Flat, unsupported sheet metal designs are naturally prone to oil-canning, especially in high-vibration environments like rooftop units or industrial air handlers. Parts fabricated “to spec” may lack the stiffness required to withstand real-world conditions.

Most vendors skip proactive DfM analysis. They also often neglect key tolerancing rules, such as maintaining minimum hole-to-bend clearance (2.5× material thickness + bend radius).

✅ YISHANG’s Proven Solution

YISHANG embeds Design for Manufacturing (DfM) into every custom project. We recommend:

  • Adding reinforcement ribs or return flanges to increase rigidity
  • Running CAD/CAM simulations to detect high-stress zones
  • Using validated stiffening patterns common in HVAC panel fabrication

The result? Sheet metal AC panels that maintain form and function, even under fluctuating thermal and mechanical loads.

📈 Procurement Benefit: Lower warranty claims, fewer site-level complaints, reduced rework.

oil-canning deformation on HVAC sheet metal panel

Failure Two: Water Ingress in Outdoor AC Sheet Enclosures

🔍 Common Symptoms

  • Internal condensation or visible rust inside enclosures
  • Electronics shorting out due to moisture
  • NEMA or IP-rated components failing in the field

Water ingress issues are especially costly in outdoor HVAC installations, telecom cabinets, or battery systems. These failures degrade sensitive electronics and frequently lead to total part replacement.

❌ What Causes It

  • Welded corner seams with micro-porosity
  • Fatigue around joints and panel corners
  • Inconsistent sealant or inadequate QA leak testing

Conventional suppliers may visually inspect welds but fail to test for leak resistance over time.

✅ YISHANG’s Proven Solution

For waterproof HVAC cabinets and IP65/IP66-rated enclosures, YISHANG applies:

  • Deep drawing for seamless housing fabrication
  • CNC TIG welding with post-process ultrasonic testing
  • Compliance with IEC 60529, UL 50, and customer-specific IP standards

Buyers receive certified leak test reports, including pressure test results, which reduce compliance workload for your QA team.

📈 Procurement Benefit: Reduced field failures, enhanced compliance documentation, protection of sensitive electronics.

waterproof HVAC enclosure with sealed corners and rain protection

Failure Three: Rust, Coating Peeling & Surface Degradation

🔍 Common Symptoms

  • Paint bubbling near welds
  • Rust forming along panel edges or mounting points
  • Premature discoloration in coastal or humid regions

These issues damage product appearance, create corrosion pathways, and often trigger return claims from end-users.

❌ What Causes It

  • Inappropriate metal choice for outdoor/humid use (e.g., untreated G90 steel)
  • Skipped or improper pretreatment before powder coating
  • Lack of compliance with surface durability benchmarks like ASTM B117

Without the correct finish system, even the best-designed enclosure will fail in challenging environments.

✅ YISHANG’s Proven Solution

We design coating systems that match your operating environment:

  • 5052 aluminum or 316 stainless steel for coastal installations
  • Multi-stage pretreatment: degrease → phosphate etch → rinse → dry
  • Powder coatings conforming to AAMA 2604/2605 for UV and corrosion resistance

Our shipments include coating reports: thickness, salt spray exposure, and pull adhesion test results. Each finished part is supported by real test data—ensuring coating reliability you can verify.

📈 Procurement Benefit: Fewer returns, longer service life, reduced total cost of ownership.

rust and peeling paint on sheet metal cabinet surface

Failure Four: Dimensional Drift Across Batches

🔍 Common Symptoms

  • Mounting holes don’t align
  • Brackets fit in one batch, but not the next
  • Angle deviations lead to line stoppage

Batch inconsistency can cripple your assembly line. In HVAC component manufacturing, where thousands of parts may feed into a complex system, even 0.5mm drift causes delays and cost overruns.

❌ What Causes It

  • Lack of springback compensation in press brake bending
  • Manual setups and outdated tooling
  • Missing process controls such as FAIR or SPC logging

Many suppliers may carry ISO 9001 certificates, but lack the real-time control infrastructure to maintain batch-level dimensional stability.

✅ YISHANG’s Proven Solution

YISHANG employs:

  • CNC press brakes with in-line angle correction
  • Automated tool wear compensation
  • First Article Inspection Reports (FAIR) verified by CMM (Coordinate Measuring Machines)
  • SPC data logging with real-time alerts

We track deviation trends and flag anomalies early, so every batch meets your tolerance stack-up requirements.

📈 Procurement Benefit: Improved line uptime, minimized rework, predictable product fit.

dimensional inspection using CMM on custom sheet metal part

Why HVAC Procurement Teams Trust YISHANG

When it comes to custom AC sheet metal parts, choosing a supplier with the right technical foundation is non-negotiable. YISHANG stands apart by combining engineering foresight with factory-scale execution:

26+ years in precision metal fabrication for HVAC, vending, energy storage, telecom, and automation
✔ Exports to 50+ countries, built to NEMA, UL, and IP compliance
✔ Certified under ISO 9001, RoHS, with FAIR and coating test reports available
✔ Manufacturing processes include:
• CNC laser cutting, bending, welding, and polishing
• Deep drawing, stamping, brushing, and surface finishing
• Powder coating with verified ASTM/AAMA compliance
✔ Application-specific support: design review, packaging solutions, multi-country shipping

📩 Need to reduce rework, speed up enclosure assembly, or eliminate leakage issues? Let YISHANG help you design right from the start. Send us your inquiry today.

YISHANG CNC sheet metal fabrication facility in China

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What is the most durable material for outdoor AC sheet metal enclosures?
A: 316 stainless steel or 5052 aluminum are recommended for their superior corrosion resistance in coastal and high-humidity environments.

Q2: How does YISHANG ensure batch consistency in fabricated metal parts?
A: Through CNC bending with real-time correction, CMM-verified FAIRs, and SPC logging during production.

Q3: Can YISHANG support OEM and ODM AC enclosure projects?
A: Yes, YISHANG offers full OEM/ODM customization, including design support, prototyping, surface finishing, and certified batch production.

We'd like to work with you

If you have any questions or need a quote, please send us a message. One of our specialists will get back to you within 24 hours and help you select the correct valve for your needs.

Get A Free Quote

All of our products are available for sampling